Lobsters to Clams

Lobsters to Clams

Locals go to the market for the fresh fish sandwiches homemade every day. The top pick is the lobster roll, one of the best on the island. The menu features an excellent selection of high end beer and wines. Eaton Seafood can ship fresh seafood anywhere in the country overnight.

By the pound mahi-mahi, shrimp and mutton snapper. Oh so good are the iced down Pink Shrimp for sale. Best in town Smoked Fish Dip.

You want to ask for in season seafood when ordering in the Florida Keys. Lobster Rolls are very good and we like the non-frozen version available when lobster season is open for the fresh catch. Get seafood sauces here, they have all sorts of yummy kinds or try the Key West Hot Sauce Shop.
Colin J.

reader feedback

Buying the Fresh Caught Seafood

Thanks for the fish buying help, and there is plenty of cat food for the wild cats! I do want to pick out a sandwich maker panini that can do footlong mahi-mahi sandwich, so perhaps we can stop at bed bath and beyond if there is time.

Emilio Z.

Eaton Seafood Market

801 Eaton Street
Key West FL 33040
305-295-3474

local map